Queens Red-Light District Booms As Prostitution Arrests Plunge 59% Under Mamdani

New York City’s long-running Roosevelt Avenue prostitution problem is back in the spotlight under Mayor Zohran Mamdani, with arrests falling sharply even as street solicitation remains visible along the Corona-Jackson Heights corridor.

According to a New York Post investigation, prostitution-related arrests along Roosevelt Avenue fell 59%. NYPD figures show 193 prostitution-related arrests through September 13 of this year, down from 468 during the same period in 2025 under former Mayor Eric Adams’ “Operation Restore Roosevelt.” The Post also reported that major crimes including murders and shootings were down 3% along the same corridor.

Despite that drop in arrests, the Post reported continued open street solicitation and activity tied to alleged illegal brothels along the roughly two-mile Roosevelt Avenue strip known as the “Market of Sweethearts.” The corridor’s problems predate Mamdani: Operation Restore Roosevelt was launched in October 2024 to target prostitution, illegal brothels, sex trafficking, unlicensed vending, and other quality-of-life concerns.

One 40-year-old Manhattan man, identified by the Post simply as “John,” said he rides the subway to Queens because he can get services for “$60 to $80,” compared with $200 to $300 in Manhattan. He also pointed to the limits of street-level enforcement, telling the paper: “The police are always around, but it seems like there’s nothing they can do.”

He added: “The women know New York laws are lax. Many come from other states… That’s what they tell me.”

Mamdani’s own record has become part of the debate. As a state assemblyman, he was listed as a co-sponsor of the original 2025 version of “Cecilia’s Act for Rights in the Sex Trades,” legislation whose stated purpose was to remove criminal penalties for consensual adult sex work while retaining laws involving minors and trafficking. During the 2025 mayoral campaign, Mamdani also said he wanted to look to the de Blasio administration’s approach to the issue, arguing that it had created “far more safety” than the Adams administration’s strategy.

Whether those policy views explain the arrest decline is not established by the arrest totals alone. But critics of the current approach are pointing directly at City Hall. One city government official told the Post: “Restore, rinse, release – that’s the problem with Roosevelt Avenue. The cops catch these johns and put them away, but they pop up like whack-a-mole. Enough is enough.”

Community activists and local leaders have continued pressing the city to use enforcement and nuisance-abatement tools against alleged illegal brothels and landlords who enable them. The Mamdani administration disputes the suggestion that it has abandoned the corridor. A City Hall representative told the Post that the mayor “is committed to partnering with local organizations and neighborhood residents to address conditions on Roosevelt Avenue” and is “using every tool available to the city while treating victims and survivors with the care and dignity they deserve.”

What is clear is that Roosevelt Avenue remains a flashpoint over how New York should balance prostitution enforcement, trafficking investigations, services for vulnerable people, and neighborhood quality-of-life concerns. Arrests are sharply lower than during last year’s crackdown, while the Post continues to report visible street-level prostitution and alleged illegal brothel activity along the corridor.